Big Barker vs Bully Beds (2020 Reviews)

We all know relaxing and rejuvenating good sleep has vital importance in our life quality. This is true not just for people, but for dogs, too! Dogs sleep approximately 12 – 18 hours a day.

Good sleep is essential for your dog to stay healthy. It is especially vital for older dogs and larger breeds who need more sleep. Unlike the floor, a bed will keep your dog warm, support arthritic joints, and prevent calluses. Instead of a couch or human bed, with a dog bed, your dog can have all to himself.

As a dog parent, you are probably aware of various choices of dog beds on the market. They have different quality, features, sizes, materials, etc. and this can make your choice overwhelming.

To make this decision easier for you, in this article, we will make a comparison between Big Barker and Bully Beds, which are the two of the most preferred brands with their high quality in the market.

If you’re trying to choose a great orthopedic bed for a large breed dog, we hope that this Bully Beds vs. Big Barker dog bed comparison will help you a lot!

The first thing is needed to say both offer excellent beds, but still, you need to choose one of them depending on your expectations. We will look at the major features of each one and describe their most popular beds. Then, we will pick one of them as a winner.

Let’s look at their foundation stories and principal motives and values of brands, first.

The History of Big Barker

The foundation history of Big Barker is based on a personal story of Erick and Hank. Hank, as a 92 lb dog had hip dysplasia in 2005. When Hank and Erick visited the vet, the vet put two options to save Hank’s life.

The first option was surgery. The other option was making everything possible to keep stress off his hips. Surely, keeping the stress of his hips was not easy, there were some necessities. One of them was keeping him sleeping on hard surfaces. His parent Eric was scared of surgery and, also, he had no budget to compensate for its costs. Therefore, Eric started to do something for the second option.

Eric admits that even though he knew to feed and to exercise Hank properly, he did not know the importance of his sleeping place. After his hip dysplasia, he realized that he should ensure Hank always slept on a comfortable, supportive surface. After he searched deeply on the internet, he could not find a bed that actually felt like a real bed to protect Hank’s hips.

This situation led him to solve the problem himself. Eric founded a company called Oh My Dog Supply in 2006. The main purpose of this company was to sell high-quality dog products produced by small manufacturers that they did not sell in the big pet stores. Then, the company specialized in dog beds and became one of the most popular dog beds in the market.

However, there was still a problem to be needed to solve! It was still not easy to find good quality items for big dogs, especially dog beds.  Eric decided to start a new company to produce superior dog beds to serve the special support needs of big dogs.

He worked with one of America’s most talented foam engineers and they together formulated 3 stage foam construction, combining comfort with durability in 2012. The company has still stuck to these three principles from a tiny little dog bed company to a member of the Inc. 5000.

Values of Big Barker

Its primary motivation that normal dog beds weren’t supportive enough for big dogs, so Big Barker wanted to build something better.

Every Big Barker product is handmade and produced by craftsmen in its workshops in Delaware and Pennsylvania. Big Barker workshops employ more than 20 experienced craftsmen and craftswomen with extensive backgrounds in upholstery and furniture production.

Its main ingredient is supportive and durable American made foam. Big Barker is proud to be made in America.

It also offers a 1-year risk-free trial of its product and gives guarantee money back if you’re not satisfied with your order.

The History of Bully Beds

The story behind the foundation of Bully Beds is also based on a personal story, the story of Bull, which was Cane Corso mastiff and was no longer alive. In 2015, Bull had hip discomfort, and his wet told his parents the reason for hip discomfort was insufficient to support of hard surface under the bed.

Then his parent Joe started to search several beds and saw that the products which are promoted as therapeutic or orthopedic are much more expensive than pet parents would like to pay, but he still wanted to provide a comfortable place to Bull. Even though Joe and his wife spent countless dollars, they did not provide enough support for Bull, which was a 150-pound frame.

Joe realized that most expensive beds were produced with poor material, and they were not waterproof. He and his wife decided to make their own. Their motivation was to produce an affordable, high-quality dog bed that provides comfort and support for a big dog.

Bully Beds did not work with engineers since they believe that foam engineers only care about the numbers. They would like to produce the products which the dogs like them. They made several pieces of research and learned the ins and outs of foam manufacturing from density to its ILD rating. When they succeeded in the formulation, they started to look for the right manufacturer.

After Bull passed away in 2016, they named their company Bully beds in his honor. Today, Bully Beds produce big dog beds not only support the weight of very big dogs, but also their products will last for decades. The company still operates in Florida as a small family business.

Values of Bully Beds

Bully Beds sells products that benefit every size of dogs, and it aims to improve dogs’ overall life qualities. Its main motivation to produce orthopedic beds for any large, aging, or arthritic dog.

It offers value at a fair price that any dog parents could afford. Bully Beds guarantees its beds for twenty years.

Bully Bed crafts dog beds made from the same memory foam used in high-end mattresses made for people. Each Bully Bed comes complete with a waterproof liner and 20-year warranty.

Comparison of Different Features

Foam/Materials

The material of the dog bed is a very important element for your dog to be comfortable and to use the bed for many years without any problems.

Both Big Barker and Bully Bed are orthopedic.

Big Barker’s main characteristic is that it has 7 inches of high-quality memory foam. Its memory foam is more than just memory foam, but rather it means a furniture grade, American crafted foam.

The Big Barker uses 2 inches of H10 comfort foam at the bottom, 3 inches of firm H45 support foam in the middle layer and, 2 inches of H10 at the top. While H45 foam holds the shape and structure of the foam, H10 foam makes the bed more comfortable.

With this sandwich design, The Big Barker offers both support and comfort in one bed. It also offers optional waterproof liners. It is completely made in the USA from foam to zipper.

On the other hand, Bully Bed offers 7 inches thick bed with 2.5 inches of 4.5Ib memory foam on the top and 4.5 inches of 2Ib support foam on the bottom. In combining these advanced functional materials, Bully Bed creates a surface that is both ultra-soft and strong – two orthopedic benefits large dogs appreciate.

Each Bully Bed products have heavy-duty, chew-resistant zippers. It offers a waterproof liner for every product and a special non-slip base.

Size and Colors

When it comes to the size of the dog bed, Big Barker is unique. It is the only brand which is designed specifically for large, extra large and giant breeds. For large dogs, they have 48”x 30” 7” beds, which are best for Labs, Golden Retrievers, Boxers, etc. If your dog is more significant than a Lab but smaller than a Great Dane you might choose extra-large one with 52”x 36” x 7”. The last option with 60”x 48” x 7”, giant one, is appropriate for Great Danes.

On the other hand, Bully Bed comes in 4 different sizes including medium, large, extra-large with 52” x 34” x 7” and, extra-extra-large with 60” x 48” x 7”.  Bully Beds also produces beds for small and medium-sized dogs. While medium offers 34” x 22”x 4”, large is designed 48” x 30” x 7”.

When it comes to color, it completely depends on your tastes! Two brands have different color options. While Big Barker offers three color options like burgundy, khaki, and chocolate, Bully Beds Dog Bed is available in the chocolate and tan colors.

Headrest

If your dog loves to cuddle up on the couch with a pillow under his heat, you might think of purchasing a bed with headrest. For Big Barker, you can choose the headrest edition, which features a raised surface for your dog to lay his head-on.

Bully Barker only offers a normal version with a level surface. However, it might not be a big factor to decide rather, it completely depends on your puppy’s habits. 

The Country of Production

If you have a question of why this is important, you need to know that the vast majority of foam inside dog beds made in China with not CertiPUR-US approved foam. However, both Big Barker and Bully Bed produce their foams in the USA with CertiPUR-US, which shows their durability and safety.

It is worth to mention that uncertified foam can also be quite dangerous, as some contain nasty chemicals like formaldehyde, phthalates, mercury, and other toxins. So, if you care about your friend’s safety and health, you should not ignore it.

Big Barker beds are 100% made in the USA. Even the zippers are made in America. Even though Bully Beds are made in America, the brand does not specify the exact type of foam.

Guarantees and Warranties

As mentioned before, Big Barker has a 10-year warranty that foam will retain 90% of its shape. If your dog’s bed flattens, Big Barker will replace it for free. It also provides a 365-day trial period, you can return it for a full refund in the case of you, or your dog do not like the bad because of any reason. 

On the other side, Bully Bed comes with a 20-year warranty and guarantees your dog bed will retain its shape and not flatten for at least 20 years. If it flattens by more than 2 inches anytime within those 20 years, Bully Bed replace it one time with no charge. This warranty is not transferrable to any other dog.

Both Big Barker and Bully Bed with their warranties probably will be the last dog bed you need to purchase for your dog!

Cleaning

Like many dogs, your dog will probably also dirty your bed, and you will need cleaning often. That is why you need to purchase an easy-to-clean dog bed.

Both brands are easy to clean and offer removable and washable outer covers to prove it.  For Big Barker, the removable cover can be zippered off easily and is made to withstand cycles in the washing machine.

On the other hand, Bully Beds adds a second cover, and a fully waterproof one to boot. If you want a waterproof cover for Big Barker, you’ll have to buy it separately.

Which One is Better?

The Big Barker and Bully Beds dog beds are very similar. Both are very high quality, are designed specifically for big dogs, and have lots of positive feedback, and both offer a long-time guarantee against the foam sinking or flattening.

However, we came to a conclusion that the dog beds of Big Barker are better when it comes to providing support for XL canines. If you have a giant dog, you can prefer Big Barker.

Since Big Barker invented a proprietary 3-stage method of construction, with a cloud-like top layer, an extra-supportive middle, and a base layer compare to two layers of foam of Bully Bed, we think that Big Barker is slightly better. On the other hand, it should be noted that Bully Bed offers cheaper options if you have a limited budget.

Winner: Big Barker

Best Selections of Big Barker

Our Top Pick: Big Barker 7" Pillow Top Orthopedic Dog Bed

Our Top Pick: Big Barker 7" Pillow Top Orthopedic Dog Bed
Big Barker 7" Pillow Top Orthopedic Dog Bed
our top pick

This product offers a 10-year warranty that it will 90% of the original shape after your purchase. It also has a 100% microfiber cover, and it has a very soft surface. 

We should state that this is closer to a human bed than a normal bed. It offers your dog a feeling like you would expect your bed to feel. It is engineered to keep your dog youthful for longer and in this therapeutic mattress, you can feel the difference even when you lay on it yourself.

Its foam is a therapeutic foam which is used expensive furniture and high-end human mattresses. The foam is also durable, comfortable, and meets CertiPUR-US standards. The Big Barker is designed to prevent sinking through the bed for the big dogs!

It supports extra relief if your dog suffers from joint pain, recovers from surgery, or faces with conditions like arthritis, hip dysplasia.

It is also easy to machine washable. This Big Barker bed is water-resistant, but not 100% waterproof.

Best for Small Breeds: Big Barker Mini - 4" Pillow Top Orthopedic Dog Bed

Big Barker Mini - 4" Pillow Top Orthopedic Dog Bed
Big Barker 7" Pillow Top Orthopedic Dog Bed
Best for Small Breeds

Although we say that Big Barker is specially designed only for large dogs, you can find nice options for small dogs in Barker Junior, a sub-brand of Big Barker. For this reason, we wanted to review this bed for you.

This Big Barker mini has the same foam technology with its best large beds, yet it specially designed for small and medium-size dogs.

This product consists of 2” H10 comfort foam and 2” H24 support foam. Its size is 27” x 18” x 4” and it comes with headrest with 2.5 contoured foam. 

Best for Crates: Orthopedic 4" Dog Crate Pad by Big Barker

Best for Crates: Orthopedic 4" Dog Crate Pad by Big Barker
Best for Crates: Orthopedic 4" Dog Crate Pad by Big Barker
Best for Crates

If your dog loves spending his time in a crate, then Big Barker Dog Crate Pad will be the perfect choice for you and your dog because of its many advantages.

It perfectly fits inside the raised lip of plastic tray in a standard 48” x 30” large crate. It offers you the highest quality foam for a crate pad. It protects your dog from touching hard plastic and metal in the crate.  This Big Barker product is 100% waterproof and protects against accidents, nesting, and digging.

This crate bad offers deep, unprecedented cushioning to your dog’s most sensitive and injury-prone areas. It is a perfect bad to avoid touching hard metal and plastics. It also helps to reduce the physical stress of your friend! 

Conclusion: Big Barker vs Bully Beds (2020 Reviews)

It is clear that both brands offer high-quality beds and are preferred by many dog parents with high-rate reviews. As we mentioned before, Big Barker looks a bit superior to Bully Beds with its foam quality, 3-layer structure, and a headrest option.  

On the other hand, however, it may be an advantage that Bully Bed offers waterproof lines in every product, and it is a bit cheaper than Big Barker.

At the end of the day, the choice depends on you and your dog’s needs. In any case, we would recommend you make sure your dog’s sleeping habits and his size requirements before choosing the dog bed that is best for your friend.

About the author: Alaaddin Sarac

I've been an avid dog enthusiast since childhood. I started this blog in hopes of helping owners find answers to questions I had after owning my first dog. This website was created as a way to share our love for all things canine with the world. From choosing the best food for your older dog to get the best beds for your tail-wagger, I aim to give you the information you need to give your dog the best care throughout his entire life.